The Best Survival Knives: A Professional Review

The Best Survival Knives

Over the past five years, I’ve made it my mission to thoroughly test and evaluate survival knives in real-world conditions. While the ESEE-6 has been my personal companion for most of that journey, I’ve put every knife in this guide through intensive testing periods to provide accurate, hands-on insights.

The Best Survival Knives: ESEE-6 ($170-190) – My Long-Term Companion

I’ve carried the ESEE-6 as my primary survival knife for the past five years, and it’s proven itself countless times. After processing countless amounts of firewood, building multiple shelters, and using it as my primary camp knife on over 30 overnight trips, I can confidently say it’s one of the best survival knives available.

The 1095 high carbon steel takes and holds an excellent edge, though I’ve learned to be diligent about oiling the blade in humid conditions. The 6.5-inch blade length hits the sweet spot between chopping capability and fine control. During a particularly challenging trip in the Smokies, I used it to process everything from small kindling to wrist-thick branches for an emergency shelter.

The micarta handles have only improved with use, providing excellent grip even when wet. The full tang construction has proven bombproof – I’ve even used it to baton through frozen oak without any signs of stress on the knife.

  • Key Features:Blade Length: 6.5 inches
  • Steel: 1095 Carbon
  • Handle: Micarta
  • Weight: 12 oz
  • Full tang construction
  • Made in USA

The Best Survival Knives: Morakniv Garberg ($80-100)

During my three-month testing period with the Garberg, I put it through a comprehensive evaluation to see if it could truly be considered the best budget survival knife. My testing included two weekend camping trips and multiple day-long field sessions focused on survival tasks.

The 14C28N stainless steel impressed me during testing, offering excellent corrosion resistance while maintaining a working edge. During a particularly wet weekend in the field, I appreciated not having to constantly oil the blade despite challenging conditions.

The Scandinavian grind proved exceptional for woodworking tasks, and I found it particularly effective for feather sticking and fine carving. I subjected the Garberg to intensive use, including batoning through hardwoods and extensive shelter-building tasks.

The Best Survival Knives: Ka-Bar BK2 Campanion ($85-100)

The BK2 entered my testing rotation for a month of intensive field use. At first, I was skeptical of its hefty weight, but during my evaluation period, this knife proved its worth as a heavy-duty survival tool.

The quarter-inch thick 1095 Cro-Van steel blade powered through splitting tasks that would challenge lighter knives. During my testing weekend in hardwood forest, the BK2 split oak rounds that I would normally tackle with a hatchet. The blade geometry, while thick, still managed detailed tasks like feather sticking, though it required more technique than thinner blades.

The Grivory handles provided excellent grip even during wet conditions, though I noticed they can become slick with muddy hands. For those seeking a nearly indestructible survival knife, my testing suggests the BK2 deserves serious consideration.

  • Key Features:Blade Length: 5.25 inches
  • Steel: 1095 Cro-Van
  • Handle: Grivory
  • Weight: 16 oz
  • Full tang construction
  • Made in USA

The Best Survival Knives: Fallkniven A1 ($280-300)

My two-month evaluation of the A1 revealed why many consider it among the best survival knives available. The laminated VG-10 steel core with stainless cladding proved exceptional during my testing, maintaining its edge through heavy use while resisting corrosion.

The convex edge geometry showed its worth during my field testing, excelling at both splitting tasks and fine cutting. During a weekend survival scenario, I used the A1 to process firewood, construct shelter frameworks, and prepare tinder – it handled each task impressively. The thermorun handle proved comfortable during extended use, though I noticed it can become slippery when wet.

  • Key Features:Blade Length: 6.3 inches
  • Steel: Laminated VG-10
  • Handle: Thermorun
  • Weight: 12 oz
  • Full tang construction
  • Made in Sweden

The Best Survival Knives: Cold Steel SRK ($65-80) – Best Budget Survival Knife Contender

My month-long testing of the SRK included two camping trips and multiple day outings. For those seeking a capable survival knife on a budget, my testing revealed the SRK offers impressive performance for its price point.

The SK-5 carbon steel handled abuse well during my evaluation, maintaining its edge through wood processing and shelter building tasks. The Kray-Ex handle provided excellent grip in all conditions, including during a unexpected rainstorm where I had to process wet wood for an emergency fire.

The Best Survival Knives: Tops BOB Fieldcraft ($150-180)

During my six-week evaluation of the BOB Fieldcraft, I found it excels as a mid-sized survival knife. The 4.5-inch blade proved surprisingly versatile during my testing trips, handling both detailed carving and moderate chopping tasks.

The 1095 steel performed admirably in my field tests, particularly during a weekend focused on bushcraft skills. The differentially tempered blade showed excellent edge retention while processing hardwoods, though I did notice it requires prompt attention in wet conditions to prevent rust. The canvas micarta handles provided outstanding grip even during a sudden downpour.

  • Key Features:Blade Length: 4.5 inches
  • Steel: 1095
  • Handle: Canvas Micarta
  • Weight: 9.5 oz
  • Full tang construction
  • Made in USA

The Best Survival Knives: Bradford Guardian 4.5 ($185-215)

My testing period with the Guardian 4.5 revealed why it’s gaining popularity in the survival community. During three intensive field sessions, the 3V steel proved exceptional, maintaining its edge through tough cutting tasks that would have dulled lesser steels.

The full flat grind excelled at food preparation and precise cutting tasks during my evaluation. While not as robust for batoning as thicker blades, I found it handled moderate splitting tasks adequately. The contoured G10 scales provided excellent control during detailed work, though I noticed they can be somewhat slick when wet.

  • Key Features:Blade Length: 4.5 inches
  • Steel: 3V
  • Handle: G10
  • Weight: 8.1 oz
  • Full tang construction
  • Made in USA

Best Survival Pocket Knife – Spyderco Paramilitary 2 ($150-170)

While fixed blades dominate survival scenarios, I dedicated a month to testing my Para Military 2 as a backup survival tool. The results pleaased me. During my testing, the S30V blade handled an impressive array of survival tasks, from creating feather sticks to processing small game.

The compression lock proved remarkably strong during testing, handling lateral forces better than most folding knives. While not a replacement for a fixed blade, it’s possibly the best survival pocket knife for backup use or when fixed blades aren’t practical.

Practical Considerations From My Testing

Through my evaluation of these knives, several key factors emerged:

  • Blade thickness significantly impacts versatility
  • Handle material becomes crucial in wet conditions
  • Edge geometry affects maintenance requirements in the field
  • Steel choice involves trading edge retention for ease of sharpening

Maintenance Insights From Field Testing

My extensive field testing revealed crucial maintenance requirements that aren’t always obvious from manufacturer specifications:

  • Carbon steel blades like the ESEE-6 and Ka-Bar BK2 need immediate attention after wet use
  • Regular stropping in the field extends time between proper sharpenings
  • Pivot tension on folding survival knives requires more frequent checking than fixed blades
  • Handle scales, especially micarta, benefit from occasional cleaning to maintain grip

The Best Survival Knives: Reccomendations Based on Testing

Best Overall Survival Knife: ESEE-6

After years with this knife and testing many others, I keep coming back to the ESEE-6. It strikes the perfect balance between capability and portability. The warranty remains the best in the industry, though I’ve never needed to use it.

Best Budget Survival Knife: Cold Steel SRK

My testing revealed performance far exceeding its price point. While it may lack the premium materials of more expensive options, it handled every survival task I threw at it competently.

Best Survival Pocket Knife: Spyderco Paramilitary 2

When a fixed blade isn’t practical, my testing showed the Para Military 2 handles survival tasks remarkably well. The compression lock proved especially reassuring during heavy use.

Task-Specific Performance Notes

Through my testing, I evaluated each knife across crucial survival tasks:

Fire Preparation

  • Scandinavian grinds (like the Garberg) excelled at feather sticks
  • Thicker blades proved better for batoning
  • 90-degree spines for ferro rods worked best on the ESEE and Morakniv

Shelter Building

  • Longer blades (ESEE-6, Fallkniven A1) handled limbing better
  • Full tang construction proved essential for battoning tasks
  • Comfort during extended use varied significantly with handle materials

Environmental Considerations

My testing across different environments revealed important factors:

Wet Environments

  • Stainless options like the Garberg required less maintenance
  • G10 and rubber handles performed better than micarta when wet
  • Coating durability became more apparent in harsh conditions

Cold Weather

  • Thicker handles proved more comfortable with gloves
  • Carbon steel showed better impact resistance in cold
  • Simpler blade geometries were easier to maintain in the field

Final Thoughts

After testing this range of survival knives, I’ve concluded that the “best” knife often depends on your specific needs and environment. However, certain features proved universally important:

  • Full tang construction is non-negotiable for primary survival knives
  • Blade length between 4.5-6.5 inches offers optimal versatility
  • Handle comfort matters more than premium steel choices
  • Simplicity often trumps complex features in survival situations

While my long-term experience with the ESEE-6 makes it my personal choice, my testing showed that each knife in this guide can serve well in survival situations when matched to the user’s needs and environment. Remember, the best survival knife is one you’re familiar with and have practiced using before you need it in an emergency.

Consider starting with the best budget survival knife that matches your needs and upgrading as you develop preferences through actual use. Regular practice with any of these knives will serve you better than an expensive blade that rarely leaves its sheath.

Scroll to Top