Best Horizontal Carry Knives: Scout Carry Options for 2025

Best Horizontal Carry Knives

After extensively testing horizontal carry knives over the past six months, I’ve discovered which models truly excel in this specialized category. Scout carry (horizontal carry) offers unique advantages for accessibility and comfort, but not all knives are well-designed for this purpose.

Bradford Guardian 3.5 ($165-185)

The Guardian 3.5 has been my go-to horizontal carry knife for the past year. The thoughtfully designed sheath system allows for multiple carry positions, but it truly excels in scout carry. During testing, the knife remained secure yet easily accessible, with no tendency to rotate or shift position.

The 3V steel blade has maintained exceptional edge retention through heavy use. The full flat grind excels at both precise cuts and general utility work. The contoured G10 scales provide excellent grip without being overly aggressive, and the handle length offers full control while remaining compact enough for comfortable horizontal carry.Key Features:

  • Blade Length: 3.5 inches
  • Steel: 3V
  • Handle: G10
  • Weight: 3.7 oz
  • Kydex sheath with modular mounting
  • Made in USA

TOPS Brakimo ($130-150)

During my two-month evaluation of the Brakimo, this purpose-built scout carry design impressed me with its practical functionality. The sheath system’s low profile and multiple attachment options make it one of the most versatile horizontal carry setups I’ve tested.

The 1095 steel blade performed admirably in field testing, though it requires more maintenance than stainless options. The handle ergonomics work particularly well in scout carry, allowing a natural draw motion without awkward wrist angles. The micarta scales provided excellent grip in all conditions.

Armatus Carry Architect ($165-185)

Testing the Architect revealed why dedicated horizontal carry designs are worth considering. The knife was specifically engineered for scout carry, and it shows in every aspect – from the sheath retention to the handle geometry during draw strokes.

The Nitro-V blade proved to be an excellent choice, offering good corrosion resistance while maintaining a keen edge through repeated use. During my testing period, I particularly appreciated how the handle design facilitates a clean draw from either direction, making it truly ambidextrous in scout carry.Key Features:

  • Blade Length: 3.25 inches
  • Steel: Nitro-V
  • Handle: G10
  • Weight: 3.4 oz
  • Kydex sheath with pull-the-dot loops
  • Made in USA

White River Knife & Tool Backpacker ($140-160)

My month-long evaluation of the Backpacker demonstrated exceptional horizontal carry comfort. The compact profile and thoughtfully designed sheath system make it nearly disappear under a belt while remaining instantly accessible.

The S35VN blade might seem short at first, but I found its length ideal for horizontal carry, preventing any awkward protrusion while maintaining full utility. The contoured micarta handles provided excellent purchase during rapid deployments, and the sheath retention struck a perfect balance between security and smooth draws.Key Features:

  • Blade Length: 3.0 inches
  • Steel: S35VN
  • Handle: Micarta
  • Weight: 2.5 oz
  • Kydex sheath with scout carry straps
  • Made in USA

Bark River Gunny Hunter ($225-250)

While not originally designed specifically for scout carry, my testing revealed the Gunny Hunter adapts exceptionally well to horizontal carry with its optional scout carry sheath. The classic design provides versatility while maintaining excellent carry characteristics.

The CPM-3V steel blade handled every task I threw at it, from food prep to light chopping. The convex grind proved especially versatile. What impressed me most was how such a capable knife could carry so comfortably in the horizontal position, thanks to the well-designed leather scout carry sheath.

Practical Considerations for Horizontal Carry

Through extensive testing of these knives, I’ve identified several crucial factors that affect horizontal carry performance:

Sheath Design

  • Retention level must balance security with smooth draws
  • Belt loops need to prevent rotation during movement
  • Drainage holes prevent moisture accumulation
  • Adjustable cant options increase versatility

Handle Geometry

  • Shorter handles typically work better for concealment
  • Smooth profiles prevent clothing snags
  • Grip texture needs to facilitate quick acquisition
  • Symmetrical designs aid ambidextrous use

Body Type Considerations

My testing with different body types revealed important insights:

Larger Frames

  • Can accommodate longer blades comfortably
  • May prefer wider spacing on belt loops
  • Often benefit from adjustable cant angles

Smaller Frames

  • Compact designs prevent overhanging
  • Thinner handles reduce printing
  • May prefer offset mounting options

Category Recommendations

Best Overall: Bradford Guardian 3.5

Offers the best combination of ergonomics, retention, and versatility for most users. The modular sheath system adapts to various carry positions while maintaining excellent deployment characteristics.

Best Value: TOPS Brakimo

Provides excellent horizontal carry performance at a more accessible price point. The simple but effective sheath design proves that good scout carry doesn’t require premium pricing.

Best Premium Option: Bark River Gunny Hunter

For those seeking a premium tool that excels in both use and carry comfort, the Gunny Hunter with scout carry sheath offers exceptional quality and versatility.

Environmental Considerations

Different environments affect horizontal carry performance:

Wet Conditions

  • Kydex sheaths generally outperform leather
  • Drainage holes become crucial
  • Stainless steels require less maintenance

Active Use

  • Secondary retention options become important
  • Shock cord backup systems prevent loss
  • Anti-rotation features prove essential

Maintenance Tips

Based on my testing, these maintenance practices ensure optimal performance:

  • Regular cleaning of sheath retention points
  • Periodic inspection of mounting hardware
  • Lubrication of friction points on leather sheaths
  • Adjustment of retention as materials break in

Final Thoughts

Horizontal carry offers unique advantages for knife accessibility and comfort, but success depends heavily on choosing the right combination of knife and sheath system. Through my testing, I’ve found that dedicated scout carry designs generally outperform adapted traditional sheaths.

Key takeaways:

  • Proper sheath design matters more than blade features
  • Consider your body type when selecting knife size
  • Quality mounting hardware is crucial for long-term satisfaction
  • Regular system checks prevent unwanted shifting or loosening

Remember that horizontal carry requires an adjustment period for both comfort and draw stroke proficiency. Take time to practice your deployment and ensure your chosen setup works with your common clothing choices before committing to everyday carry.

Whether you choose a dedicated scout carry design or adapt a traditional knife, prioritize security and accessibility in your selection. The best horizontal carry knife is one that stays secure, deploys smoothly, and carries comfortably throughout your daily activities.

Scroll to Top